African American Reparations Negative2 Essay - 1786 Words

African American Reparations Negative We negate the resolution, Resolved: The United States Federal Government ought to pay reparations to African Americans Framework: First, This debate revolves around the idea of race relations. At that point, the team that is best able to evaluate the root cause of racism should win the round. If we prove that reparations don’t solve for the underlying issues of racism, a negative ballot is in line. Second, the topic uses the phrase â€Å"pay reparations to African Americans†. At that point, the basis of the affirmative is to interact with the African Americans themselves. Contention 1 Subpoint A: The root cause of racism is the structures of economic inequality, which reparations can’t fix. Nuruddin ‘1†¦show more content†¦Wealth is often accumulated through inheritance; thus the origins of this widening divide may be traced back many generations. The Civil Rights movement dismantled American apartheid (de jure segregation--but certainly not de facto segregation as a tour through any of Americas chocolate inner cities and vanilla suburbs will reveal), qualitatively transforming the landscape of civil liberties, access and opportunities for African Americans. Yet the dismantling of the social and political aspects of American apartheid has not led to African American community empowerment or development, just as the dismantling of the social and political aspects of Zimbabwean and South African apartheid has not led to national reconstruction in those societies, because in all three cases, the economic resources (including the land and the mineral wealth--all ill-gotten gains) remained concentrated in the hands of whites. When actions such as the civil rights movement occurred, white people still took economic resources from group they were trying to help. Subpoint B: The root cause of racial subjugation is capitalism, and reparations movements will fail within it. Burkett ‘8 (Maxine Burkett- Associate Professor of Law, University of Colorado Law School.- 2008- â€Å"Reconciliation and Nonrepetition: A New Paradigm for African-American Reparations† P.